Australian Art Education
Volume 12 number 1, June 1988
Paid downloads
Muriel Hilson
This paper argues that influences from Discipline-Based Art Education seem likely to lead to an even greater neglect than exists at the moment of the study of prepatriarchal societies and artefacts in the art history class, reinforcing gender-biased assumptions about the nature of early civilisations. In pursuing this argument, the writer will, in the words of Bertha Eckstein-Diener (1929) endeavour to "remain as one-sided as possible, one-sided in that direction which has never so far enjoyed a graphic representation. The other side is fairly well known..."
pp 8-13
Penny McKeon
This paper proposes a model for a theory of art history education which is coherent with the principles of discipline-based art education. The model represents a structure which is both appropriate to the aesthetic and artistis interests of the visual arts and art history and in harmony with the general scholarly practices of history. It is complete in providing sufficient conditions for the generation of warranted art historical examination.
pp 14-23
Warren Left and Lee Emery
An analysis is presented of a set of 'requested works' provided by students to the National Gallery of Victoria, on the theme, 'My Backyard', The ages of the students ranged from 4 to 16. The analysis sought to make inferences about the categories of response to the FIXed topic, and to identify the nature of children's thinking as they worked on compositional problem solving. Eleven content categories were identified. Nearly 60% of the students produced predominantly literal responses, with a mean age of 11.5. Self preoccupied responses fell at the mean age of 6.6 years, and more abstract thinking was evidenced at the older age levels. It is argued that representational diversity is difficult to achieve, since cultural norms under 'requested' conditions operate so as to veil possible diversity of thinking.
pp 24-35
Graeme Sullivan
Theory development in art education has given rise to numerous paradigms which have provided various orientations to the structure of the field. While the formulation of theory is considered an ideal outcome of inquiry, the crucial role of verification is often overlooked. This paper describes an empirical method of theory testing. Models of symbolic functioning which were based on theoretical views of the researchers at Harvard Project Zero were defined and tested using recently developed methods of multivariate analysis. As a result of this testing, areas of inadequacy were highlighted.
pp 36-47
Gerry King
Paper presented at the Philippines International Conference of Education Through An, INTERNTIONAL SOCIETY FOR EDUCATION THROUGH ART. Manila, Philippines, 1987.
Evolution is an eminently desirable means of orchestrating change. Evolution is respectable; minimises confrontation; maximises existing resources and avoids the scars of battle. Evolution allows seeds of ideas to grow to maturity; many perspectives to become a unified vision; rough diamonds to be polished. When it is successful it is very much so, hut when it fails it does so absolutely. Evolution, however, does not serve all the needs of change.
Peter E. Hiller
This paper comments on observations made during a period of study leave in New York and London. Approximately six months was spent in each city. This included work in New York City and New York State as well as some time spent in Rhode Island and Boston. This was followed by a period based at the Institute of Education, University of London and included study in and around London and its southern regions. This study focused on the role, status and structure of visual arts education from Kindergarten to Year 12 and included observations of some art teacher education programs. The paper comments on selected elementary/primary schools and art teacher education programs in each locality, and makes some general comments about how such a review might be beneficial to the situation in Australia.
pp 52-56



