Volume 33 Special Edition 1, 2010
Paid downloads
Dr Joanna Barbousas
Australian Catholic University
Current consultation processes and draft documents for the representation of ‘The Arts: Initial Advice Paper (ACARA, 2010) have brought to the frontline debates about discipline knowledge, formation of ‘practices’, and normalised assumptions about ‘the arts’ in educational terms. Declarations and statements that have been declared and positioned as knowledge in documentation that support the formation of an Australian Curriculum are ways to trace the power formations masked by democratic rhetoric and collaborations. This paper reports on an ongoing investigation of the political agenda mapped through statements used to declare a particular kind of curriculum change. To understand the inclusion and exclusion of discourses in the proposed Australian Curriculum is to count and account for field presence.
Add to cartDr Althea Francini
Independent Scholar
This paper responds to The Arts: Initial Advice Paper (ACARA, 2010) in the proposed National Curriculum, concentrating on problems in two major areas. The first part considers the basic assumptions, or philosophical foundation. The second looks at the curriculum’s strand organisation. The conceptual foundation is divisive in its approach to how learning occurs and strongly inconsistent with current knowledge. The strand organisation under a general set of verb terms is unsustainable. The terms are generic to any practice and not helpful theoretically or practically for defining a coherent learning experience in visual arts.
Add to cartKaren Maras
Australian Catholic University
This paper evaluates the provision for critical practice in the Visual Arts, Kindergarten to Year 8, in The Arts: Initial Advice Paper (ACARA, 2010). Focusing on the strand of Responding, the scope and theoretical assumptions underpinning this proposal will be aligned with the theory of critical meaning, typically represented in Year 7 students’ critical reasoning about artworks. How and on what terms a 12-year-old student explains and justifies a critical judgement is analysed to illustrate the basis on which they construct a point of view about art. This reveals a significant mismatch between students’ own theories of critical meaning and those underlying the form of art criticism in the proposed curriculum structure. The notion of ‘responding’ as an appropriate representation of what it means to interpret artworks is found to be questionable. Rather than supporting students’ development, this provision ignores students’ own theoretical structures. Learning is therefore compromised. This assessment of just one aspect of what should be a forward-looking, 21st century curriculum reveals a lowest-common-denominator approach to Visual Arts education has been adopted.
Add to cartDr Susanne Jones
The Arts Unit New South Wales Department of Education and Training
The Arts: Initial Advice Paper (ACARA, 2010) makes the common-sense assumption that the ubiquity of technology and photographic imagery make them easy for children to use and understand. While there is merit in the concept that familiarity improves understanding, without instruction and cognitive challenge, it can foster stereotypes and rigid thinking. This paper draws on recent research (Jones 2007), the work of Liben (2003), Karmiloff-Smith (1992), Berti and Freeman (1997), to show how constraints on children’s pictorial reasoning affect pictorial representation at different cognitive developmental stages. Without reflection, the ubiquity of photographic imagery in young Australian’s lives, inhibits development of the reflexive thinking required to use a digital camera to make innovative images, that also reflect their intention.
Add to cartKristen Murray
Kegworth Public School, NSW Department of Education and Training
Sustainability, one of the three perspectives to be represented in the Australian Curriculum, has a great contribution to make to Visual Arts and as a legacy for our community. The Visual Arts is well placed to respond to this perspective. The benefits of this perspective for primary generalist teachers, in particular, is that they will be encouraged to replace the neat predictability of packaged, coloured squares and embrace the found, the old, the second-hand, the dirty or the damaged in making artworks. This emphasis has many benefits for primary students and schools and the kinds of artworks students make and value.
Add to cartDonna Mathewson Mitchell
Charles Sturt University
Teachers in Visual Arts classrooms regularly address the subject matter of artistry. However, the practices of teachers are themselves examples of artistry. A conception of teaching as artistry recognizes the complex and relational nature of teaching as a professional practice that develops over time. In exploring the artistry of teaching, this paper presents a relational framework for investigating teaching practice. The framework is used to investigate the potential impact of current educational reforms in Australia on the artistry of teaching. Discussion explores implications for the teaching profession, for secondary visual arts teaching and for initial teacher education.
Add to cartDr Kerry Thomas
School of Art History and Art Education, College of Fine Arts,
University of New South Wales
The Arts: Initial Advice Paper (ACARA, 2010) defines creativity in terms of the development of ideas new to an individual and seeing an existing situation in a new way. Their approach is underscored by a mid-twentieth-century modernist and psychological conception of creativity. It is further augmented by the status accorded to the strands of generating, realising and responding as ‘experiences’ common to the arts. These strands, along with the definition of creativity, misconstrue how something original, innovative and of value to the visual arts is produced that advances students’ creative interests. My ethnographic studies reveal a markedly different account of creative practice. Taking selected cases from secondary art classrooms I show that creativity is an inherently social practice transacted between expert teachers and students in making art. Creativity is a product of an embodied, although overlooked, history that accrues in its value through reiterative compromises between teachers and students in the genesis of possibilities and in the resolution of artworks.
Add to cartWendy Ramsay
Curriculum Consultant Visual Arts K-12 New South Wales Department of
Education and Training
Future directions position the study of Asia as a mandatory, cross-curriculum dimension in the proposed Australian Curriculum (Assessment and Reporting Authority,2010). The study of Visual Arts requires a rigorous content framework to develop informed attitudes and values and facilitate coherent, well-informed viewpoints. The functionality of content in NSW Visual Arts syllabi provide a platform for establishing a sustained and layered dialogue with the art world, through authentic interaction between artists, artworks, audiences and interests of the world. Multirepresentational exhibitions are a catalyst for the active construction of knowledge and primary engagement with the agencies of the art world. They provide meaningful intersections between artists, artworks, diverse audiences and ideas. Exhibiting contemporary Asian artists fosters and sustains understanding and connects audiences with critical political and social issues, diverse art practice and the voices of artists, curators, critics and writers. Essential learning will need to address a network of procedures that underpin practice as making and studying in the Visual Arts with a continuum of learning that acknowledges conceptual shifts in students’ understanding over time. The current rubric for the HSC Art Criticism and Art History written examination and years 7-10 Visual Arts outcomes in NSW are crucial sites of reflection for learning experiences that provide a scaffold for students to present a well-reasoned and informed point of view. This paper will provide a reflective framework which locates NSW Visual Arts syllabuses as sites of knowledge and understanding of Visual Arts practices, with the study of Asia as cross-curriculum content in the proposed Australian Curriculum.
Add to cartWesley Imms
University of Melbourne
Recent debate has highlighted the extraordinary range of interests that will need to co-inhabit a very small amount of time and space in the new arts National Curriculum. This paper moves away from a ‘large picture’ discussion of this problem to present a more practical and personal perspective. It will suggest that answers lie within our very artistic practice. Visual Arts’ long term wellbeing will not be dictated by the structure of the Australian Curriculum document, rather by the way we ‘inhabit’ that construct, whatever form it takes, and this inhabitation must recognise the multiple and varied post-schooling pathways our students take using the skills we provide them with. To argue this point, the paper will use the author’s own art making as a metaphor for how we should be approaching the creation of this new space, referencing briefly the philosophies of de Botton, Foucault and Bachelard, who all explore the interplay of space, place and inhabitation. The paper will argue that creating a new place for Visual Art in any Australian Curriculum is not dissimilar to the process we take when creating and inhabiting our own personal places.
Add to cart


